High Court rules on inheritance dispute between siblings over £40,000 property

News Article

The High Court has ruled on an inheritance dispute between two siblings over their mother’s £40,000 property.

Three siblings were involved in the dispute, with two of the siblings accusing their brother, Edward McCarthy of pressuring their mother to change her Will and leave the property to him as the sole beneficiary.

Their mother, Margaret Wilcox, died in 2016 after suffering from Alzheimer’s disease. Mr McCarthy had helped his mother purchase the property from the local authority for a discounted price of approximately £17,000, and his mother’s Will had subsequently been re-drafted, with two family friends present as witnesses.

His two siblings were due to receive 15 per cent of the property each, under the original Will, and argued that their mother had a poor memory and signed her final Will under duress, without understanding the full implications.

However, the court agreed with the assertion that Mrs Wilcox would have wanted her soon to have the property after she died as he had helped her purchase the house.

This case comes as the number of Wills disputed at the High Court reached an all-time high, with 188 cases heard in 2019.

There are several key reasons for this rise, including recent research which found that a significant number of adults in the UK do not have a Will, while the complex nature of modern families can also present challenges.

Dominic Green, a Solicitor with Palmers who specialises in Will disputes, said: “Ensuring that you have a valid and up-to-date Will is essential to avoid any issues further down the line, and to give you peace of mind.

“Seeking professional advice ensures that your affairs are in order, and avoids any costly mistakes in the future.”

For help and advice on matters relating to Wills, inheritance and estate planning, contact our expert team.


We want to protect you and our staff from the spread of coronavirus.

We would kindly request, where possible, that you contact us by telephone or email in preference to attending personally at our offices.

If you are feeling unwell or have been in contact with anyone who is unwell, please do not visit our offices.

Where possible, please send correspondence and documentation to us electronically so that we are able to progress matters remotely if necessary. Thank you for your co-operation.